analysis of the criminalisation of cartel activity in the United Kingdom.

  • 57 Pages
  • 4.61 MB
  • English
by About the Edition

This thesis considers the criminalisation of individual participation in cartel activity in the UK under the Enterprise Act 2002. It presents an analysis of the relevant sections of the Act, considers the impact of criminalisation, and highlights problematic areas that the legislation invokes in this specialised and complex area of legal regulation.

The Physical Object
Pagination57 leaves.
ID Numbers
Open LibraryOL19215040M
ISBN 100494022337

Cartel activity in the UK may be punished using both civil and criminal law. The civil enforcement regime is contained in Chapter I of the Competition Act (CA98) and closely mirrors its EU equivalent, Article of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU).Chapter I CA98 prohibits agreements or concerted practices between two or more undertakings which have the object or.

Criminalising Cartels: Theory and Practice in the UK and Australia which aim to explain the justification for the criminalisation of cartels In addition, a hybrid approach30 will be described. Deterrence Theory (a) The Basis of the Deterrence Theory The deterrence theory, based on a utilitarian philosophy,31 requires a reasonFile Size: KB.

A global trend towards the criminalisation of cartel activity can be detected at present. What was once primarily a US phenomenon has become an international one, with countries as diverse as Israel, Brazil, and Australia pursuing a policy of cartel criminalization.

How oversight killed the criminalisation of cartels. deterring and prosecuting cartel activity in South Africa, and the world. Accordingly, the effect section 73A will have on analysis of the criminalisation of cartel activity in the United Kingdom. book CLP is highly significant.

This appears to be the route taken in other jurisdictions such as Australia and the United Kingdom. However, it must be said that. United Kingdom Historically, the United Kingdom did not impose criminal sanctions on cartelists.

The imprisonment of a cartelist was seen as a disproportionate action with little to no additional deterrent effects. This position radically changed with the inclusion Author: Luke Danagher. Republic, South Korea, Switzerland, th e United Kingdom and the United Stat es.

Many of these did not have Many of these did not have criminal cartel laws prior to the mids. This paper shows how South Africa and the United Kingdom deal with this task by introducing criminal sanctions into their competition law for individuals engaging in cartel conduct.

As the criminal law is the ultima ratio of a constitutional state, its introduction into competition law needs some justification.

This criminalisation of cartel conduct is a firm step indeed. A person convicted of a section 73A offence is liable for imprisonment not exceeding 10 years and/or a fine not exceeding R Since section 73A comprises criminal conduct, prosecution of the directors or managers of a firm will be conducted by the National Prosecuting Authority.

Criminalisation of Cartel Behaviour. Two key assumptions underpin this analysis. First, criminalisation makes the morality of serious cartel activity a relevant consideration in the design and. Section 73A of the Competition Amendment Act, which governs the criminalisation of cartel conduct, has been in the draft rulebook for over 8 years, but.

This book is inspired by the international movement towards the criminalisation of cartel conduct over the last decade.

Led by US enforcers, criminalisation has been supported by a growing number of regulators and governments. It derives its support from the simple yet forceful proposition that criminal sanctions, particularly jail time, are the most effective deterrent to such activity.

The Enterprise Act: Criminalisation of cartelsby Elizabeth Morony and Luke Tolaini, Clifford Chance LLPRelated ContentThe most controversial element of the Enterprise Actwhich received Royal Assent on 7th November,is the introduction of a criminal offence for individuals who dishonestly enter into cartel Practical Law trialTo access this resource, sign up for a.

However, as the harm from hard core cartel activity strikes at an important institution which permits an individual's ability to secure their own well‐being in a liberal society, criminalisation of hard core cartel behaviour can have its normative justification on this basis.

Vol Issue 3. September Cited by: 2.

Details analysis of the criminalisation of cartel activity in the United Kingdom. PDF

Legal Certainty and Cartel Criminalisation within the EU Member States - Volume 71 Issue 3 - Peter WhelanCited by: 4. 'Cartels, Markets and Crime advances a normative justification of the criminalisation of cartel conduct based on Rawls’ Theory of Justice.

It is an interesting addition to the literature, much of which is dominated by law and economics theories and contentions.' Brent Fisse Source: Criminal Law and Criminal Justice Books ()Cited by: 5. The criminal cartel offence will apply to an agreement outside the United Kingdom only if it is, or is intended to be, implemented in the United Kingdom.

Investigations Initiating an investigation. cartel activity in the economy cannot be known. Therefore the following overview of global cartel activity relates to the minority of cartels that have been discovered, which is lower than the total number of cartels.

The following information draws on a data set for international cartels, not all of which operated in Australasia5: a. A defence of honestly believing that the cartel provision was reasonably necessary for the collaborative activity; and A two-year transitional period before all this comes into force.

In a statement, the new Minister of Commerce and Consumer affairs, Kris Faafoi, said that “this government wants to take a strong stance against business people. Fail / Withdrawn: A bill fails if the vote is lost at first, second, or third reading.

The member in charge of a bill may withdraw it. _____ Note: this simple progress display does not. Abstract. This article aims to critically discuss the extent to which cartels have become a criminal activity.

In doing so, attention will be paid to the relative competition provisions of the United States (US), the European Union (EU), the United Kingdom (UK), and : Luke Danagher.

Download analysis of the criminalisation of cartel activity in the United Kingdom. PDF

Cartel activity is prohibited under EU law by virtue of Article (1) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union.

Firms that violate this provision face severe punishment from those entities responsible for enforcing EU competition law: the European Commission. The Anti-Cartel Enforcement Industry: Criminological Perspectives on Cartel Criminalisation Christopher Harding 'The Battle for Hearts and Minds': The Role of the Media in Treating Cartels as Criminal Andreas Stephan PART G FUTURE CHALLENGES FACING CARTEL CRIMINALISATION ON AN INTERNATIONAL SCALE A Lack of Public and Political Support 6 Angus MacCulloch, ‘The cartel offence and the criminalisation of United Kingdom competition law’ () Journal of Business Lawincarceration should deter individuals from participating in cartel activity, or if theyFile Size: KB.

The Cartel Offence and the Criminalisation of United Kingdom Competition Law. / MacCulloch, Angus D. In: Journal of Business Law, No. 5,p. Research output: Contribution to journal ›. Cartels, Markets and Crime: A Normative Justification for the Criminalisation of Cambridge CB2 8BS, United Kingdom Published in the United States of America by Cambridge University Press, New York 1 A normative approach to the criminalisation of cartel activity 18 Liberalism and the harm to others justification of the criminal law 18File Size: KB.

To fill this void, I develop a normative (or principled) justification for the criminalisation of conduct characteristic of ‘hard core’ cartels.

The paper opens with a brief consideration of the rhetoric commonly used to denounce cartel activity, eg that it ‘steals from’ or ‘robs’ by: 2. The Cartel Project Bulletin Project genesis The Cartel Project is an interdisciplinary research Cartel criminalisation in this country is consistent with a global trend towards tougher, more penal, anti-cartel law groundswell of concern by the public in relation to cartel activity.

Cartels – The Case for Criminalisation in the European Union Gráinne Hawkes A cartel is a horizontal agreement to fix prices, allocate customers or territories, restrict output or rig bids and is considered as the most pernicious and egregious form of violation of competition law.

Description analysis of the criminalisation of cartel activity in the United Kingdom. EPUB

It is File Size: KB. The concept of criminalisation, however, has a deeper and more precise theoretical legacy. Formative traces can be found in an interactionist school of sociology of the s. Tannenbaum (), for example, argued that deviance, rather than being a self-evident behavioural entity, could only be created through a process of social interaction.

incentives to report cartel activity when discovered. This is the third edition of The Cartels and Leniency Review. We hope that you will find it a useful resource.

The views expressed in this book are those of the authors and the United Kingdom’s Competition and Markets Authority (CMA)) does not have the power to impose fines. Fourth. History of the proposed criminalisation. New Zealand’s journey towards the criminalisation of cartel conduct could be described, in the words of one Member of Parliament, as a ‘Homeric epic’.

On 13 Octoberthe Commerce (Cartels and Other Matters) Amendment Bill was introduced to Parliament.Competition authorities particularly in the United Kingdom, the United States and Australia have enacted and entrenched criminal penalties for cartel behaviour. South Africa seems to desire to follow suit although the amendments to our Competition Act, (“Competition Act”) in relation to criminal sanctions have yet to come into operation.Increasing Criminalisation of Cartel Activity in the International Arena Over the last decade, there has been an increasing trend internationally to impose criminal sanctions on individuals in respect of hardcore cartel activity.

The table below highlights key jurisdictions and the criminal sanctions that can currently be imposed on individuals1.